Validation rules

BR-E-09 — EN 16931 rule

The tax amount (BT-117) of the exempt (E) breakdown must be 0.

Rule: BR-E-09 — official EN 16931 / XRechnung rule
Severity: error
Business term: BT-117 — VAT category tax amount
Field in your JSON: invoice.lines
Detected by: tier 3 — KoSIT validator (authoritative)
Reachability: Triggerable from your request JSON (generate & validate)

How to fix it

Set line.vat to 0 on E lines (and vat: 0 on E allowances/charges) — any other rate makes normbill compute non-zero VAT for the group.

BR-E-09 auf Deutsch — was bedeutet der Fehler?

Der Steuerbetrag (BT-117) der steuerbefreiten Aufschlüsselung (E) muss 0 sein — der KoSIT-Validator lehnt die Rechnung sonst ab.

So beheben Sie den Fehler

Setzen Sie line.vat auf 0 bei E-Positionen (und vat: 0 bei E-Nachlässen/-Zuschlägen); jeder andere Satz führt zu berechneter Umsatzsteuer in der Gruppe.

Related rules

BR-46 — A VAT breakdown (BG-23) has no tax amount (BT-117).
BR-CO-17 — A VAT breakdown's tax amount (BT-117) does not equal its taxable amount (BT-116) multiplied by the category…
BR-DEC-20 — A VAT category tax amount (BT-117) uses more than 2 decimal places — EN 16931 allows at most 2.
BR-AE-09 — The tax amount (BT-117) of the reverse-charge (AE) breakdown must be 0.
BR-AF-09 — The tax amount (BT-117) of an IGIC (L) breakdown must equal its taxable amount (BT-116) multiplied by its…
BR-AG-09 — The tax amount (BT-117) of an IPSI (M) breakdown must equal its taxable amount (BT-116) multiplied by its…

Official sources

Every 422 from the API lists the rule id, the path in your request JSON, a plain-language message and a suggested fix — see the docs overview for the report format.

Or try it live: drop any XRechnung XML on the free validator — same KoSIT-backed report, no account.